A workflow run on GAL-38 dispatched a plan to @check that contained a
self-contradicting "Wait, the movement should be direct position
assignment, not delta… Let me reconsider…" passage with two versions
of the same move_enemies code, plus drop-in cargo-pasted match arms /
function bodies (plan-as-implementation). The rules added in 832306c
caught these patterns when @make was the recipient but did not cover
the plan itself, plan-review dispatches, test-author dispatches, or
final-review dispatches.
Hoists the Finalized-Text Rule and Pre-Dispatch Validation table out
of Phase 5/7 into a new top-level "Dispatch Hygiene" section between
Phase 3 and Phase 4, and adds an explicit "No-Implementation-in-Plan-
or-Spec Rule" that bans drop-in code blocks > ~5 lines, full function
bodies, and stage-by-stage transformations from plans and specs alike.
Phases 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 each gain a one-line pointer requiring the
orchestrator to apply Dispatch Hygiene before sending. Phase 5's
former "Code Context Anti-patterns" becomes "Code Context — what to
include" with positive framing, deferring the negative list to the
hoisted rules. The Phase 6 stub-first section's stale anti-pattern
reference is updated to point at Dispatch Hygiene as well.
Harald Hoyer
17ad3ba6ef